MUSIC 256 - Music Since 1900
Laura Gray
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
Table of contents
The Era & its Music
Music Since 1900. What is this era? Time frame: 20th Century; 21st Century?
Do we define the era based on dates or other factors?
Cohesion? Is there an overriding style or structure?
co-existing diversity:
- Many contrasting trends (“isms”)
- styles, forms, techniques, nature of music
Relationship with past
- had to compete for concert stage with classics of the past
- self-consciously “modern” (1889-1918)
- founded on past but need to break away:
- quest for originality:
- every work an artistic statement
- challenge the past:
- Functional tonality, goal-driven structures
- Some radical breaks with the past
- not a steady “development”:
- decisive moments/events
19th-Century Precedents
We trace precedents on 2 paths:
- Austro-German tradition
- non-Germanic, French/Russian traditions
Prelude to Tristan und Isolde
RICHARD WAGNER (1813-1883), Prelude to Tristan und Isolde (1859/65 premiere)
Stretched the bounds of tonality through:
- Increased chromaticism:
- distant keys & stepwise melodic motion
- Prolonged dissonance
- Less dependence on keys that support the central tonic
decisive historical “moment”
- “crisis in Romantic harmony” (E. Kurth)
- 1st chord in 5-hour opera:
- 4 dissonant chords in a row
- g# b d# f: ambiguous function
- Conflation of 2 chromatic Leitmotifs
- recurring themes attached to characters, concepts, objects
- Tonic chord (A minor) & cadences avoided
- deepens tension & resolution of tonality: for drama
- Clear resolution at very end of opera
The idle, noisy day is over
MODEST MUSORGSKY(1839-81): “The idle, noisy day is over”, Song No. 3 from Sunless (1874)
Strong key of C: anchor, but freely roams:
- Introduces “foreign” elements (B♭ & A♭)
- Juxtaposition of chords for colour only, not tonal function: G♭
- e.g., G♭triad –> G7 chord (mm. 6-7, 14)–> C
- Chromatic melody: moves by step
- Whole-tone scale suggested (voice, mm35-36)
- Influenced Debussy: piano, m16ff: Debussy borrowed pattern in Nuages
Nuages gris
FRANZ LISZT (1811-1886), Nuages gris (Grey Clouds, 1881)
key signature & tonic triad (m.2 G B♭D) suggests g minor, but rejects traditional harmonic functions
Points to exhaustion of tonality, anticipates the crisis:
- Highly chromatic: semitone movement
- Augmented triad = central harmonic unit (= 2 major 3rds)
- Parallel movement vs conventional chord progressions
- Static bass line: oscillates B♭ - A
- Avoids cadence structure, even very end of piece
- Last chord = Augmented triad (E♭G B) + A
- = 4 notes from whole-tone collection: A E♭G B
E♭[F] G A B [C#]
- = 4 notes from whole-tone collection: A E♭G B
French Modernism I: Debussy
Claude Debussy (French, 1862-1918): Different direction: “pleasure in the moment”
Some Influences and Inspiration:
- sought independence from Austro-German tradition: Wagner
- French tradition
- Russians: Musorgsky
- medieval music
- Asia: Javanese gamelan; Chinese & Japanese music
- Impressionist painters & Symbolist poets
Some keys to Debussy’s style:
- common-practice harmony avoided, weakened:
- tonal focus remains: but without chordal functional relationships; quasi-independent chords
- undermines need to resolve: no urgency or drive towards end goal
- creates, juxtaposes musical images:
- themes & motives: not developed
- dissonances: don’t need to resolve
- Sonorities/chords move in parallel motion
- instrumental timbres/colours intrinsic to musical content
- contrasts of scale types, exotic scales
- some scales used by Debussy: whole-tone, pentatonic, octatonic
- Impressionism : music that evokes moods & visual imagery through colourful harmony & instrumental timbre
- a) Monet: through colour & light: Monet, “Impression: Sunrise”, 1874
- b) Debussy: through harmony & tone colour
“Nuages” from Nocturnes
“Nuages” from Nocturnes (1897-99, premiered in 1900 & 1901):
title: “Nocturnes”, focus on colour
form: A B A’: typical 3-part form
large orchestra: for colour
- divided muted strings: “shimmer”
- dabs of colour: brief motives (2 or 3 notes)
interaction of tone colour with motive, scale type
- oscillating pattern fifths, thirds
- modelled on Musorgsky, Sunless piano acc’t
- appearances feature different tone colours, pitches
- octatonic English horn motive: c# d e f b (m.5)
- motive never developed, transposed, always English horn
- complete identification between timbre and motive
- middle section (B) of “Nuages”:
- 1889: Paris Universal Exposition: “Decisive moment”
- Javanese gamelan: Indonesian orchestra – mostly gongs & percussion
- 1889: Paris Universal Exposition: “Decisive moment”
- pentatonic tune & similar articulation (harp & flute)
French Modernism II: Maurice Ravel
Maurice Ravel (1875–1937) : some characteristics
- often grouped with Debussy as impressionist
- outsider, independent streak
- impressionist works: strong musical imagery, colorful harmonies
- Interest in Classic forms, genres
- French tradition: stylized dances, suite
- Varied Influences:
- a) French symbolism
- b) Jazz elements, Blues
- c) Viennese Waltz
- d) Spanish idioms
- e) French/Russian
Ravel, Rapsodie espagnole (NAWM 173)
- orchestral suite in 4 movements: I “Prélude à la nuit” & II “Malagueña”
- multiple influences: evocations of Spain, authentic flavour & Rimsky-Korsakov
NAWM 173a: I “Prélude à la nuit” (Night Prelude)
- Dynamics: mostly quiet
- Repeating figure (ostinato): F-E-D-C#
- Opening: descending pattern: muted strings, duple meter
- Evokes Spanish accompaniment pattern
- Ambiguous: d minor scale or octatonic?
- Creates nocturnal mood
- M14: clarinets: Seguidilla-like gestures
- M28: diatonic string melody, woodwind flourishes (e.g., 2 bassoons)
- Ends on A
NAWM 173b : II “Malagueña” = a Spanish dance or song in flamenco style
- Triple meter Phrygian mode
- Usually in 2 parts
- Opening:
- plucking low string ~ guitar
- Repeating descending 4-note pattern ~ flamenco guitar pattern
- Muted trumpet: new f#-minor melody based on 4-note pattern
- Second part (m.73): Song in Flamenco style: English horn
- Closing (79): Return of 4-note pattern from I: F-E-D-C#
- Played on celesta