ME 322: Mechanical Design 1

Estimated study time: 10 minutes

Table of contents

Sources and References

Primary texts: Shigley’s Mechanical Engineering Design by Budynas and Nisbett (McGraw-Hill); Machine Design: An Integrated Approach by Norton (Pearson); Fundamentals of Machine Component Design by Juvinall and Marshek.

Supplementary texts: Mechanical Engineering Design by Ugural; Roark’s Formulas for Stress and Strain by Young, Budynas, and Sadegh; Design of Machine Elements by Faires.

Online resources: MIT OpenCourseWare 2.72 Elements of Mechanical Design; ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code excerpts; AISC and CSA welding standards; SAE fastener torque references.


Chapter 1: The Design Process and Design Philosophy

1.1 Iteration and Synthesis

Mechanical design is an iterative synthesis that transforms a need statement into manufacturable drawings and specifications. Iteration alternates between creative synthesis of alternatives and analytic evaluation, narrowing from many concepts to one design ready for production.

1.2 Specifications and Constraints

The client need is translated into functional requirements, performance targets, and constraints. Standards (ASME, ISO, CSA, ASTM) govern materials, fasteners, welds, and pressure vessels. Specifications clarify the boundary between the engineered artefact and its operating environment.

1.3 Factor of Safety

A factor of safety \( n \) provides margin against uncertainty:

\[ n = \frac{\text{strength}}{\text{stress}}. \]

Selection of \( n \) balances knowledge of loads, material variability, consequence of failure, and cost. Probabilistic design supplements deterministic \( n \) with target reliabilities.

Design for reliability. The discipline of demonstrating that an engineered system will perform its intended function over a specified life under stated conditions with a defined probability of success.

Chapter 2: Stress Analysis

2.1 Multiaxial Stresses

Stress at a point is described by a symmetric tensor with three principal stresses \( \sigma_1, \sigma_2, \sigma_3 \). Mohr’s circle visualises the transformation of stresses with rotation. Principal stresses are the eigenvalues of the stress tensor.

2.2 Stress Concentrations

Geometric discontinuities concentrate stress. The elastic stress concentration factor \( K_t = \sigma_{max}/\sigma_{nominal} \) depends on geometry. Design charts from Peterson’s Stress Concentration Factors quantify \( K_t \) for common features. Ductile materials often redistribute stress plastically at static loads, so the full \( K_t \) is usually applied only to fatigue.

2.3 Combined Loading

Shafts and brackets experience combined tension, bending, and torsion. Superposition of individual stress fields builds the combined stress state, which is then evaluated against a failure criterion.

Chapter 3: Static Failure Theories

3.1 Ductile Materials

For ductile materials, the distortion-energy (von Mises) criterion predicts yield when

\[ \sigma' = \sqrt{\tfrac{1}{2}\left[(\sigma_1-\sigma_2)^2+(\sigma_2-\sigma_3)^2+(\sigma_3-\sigma_1)^2\right]} = S_y. \]

The maximum-shear-stress (Tresca) criterion predicts yield when \( \sigma_1 - \sigma_3 = S_y \). Both criteria agree to within about 15% for typical biaxial stress states.

3.2 Brittle Materials

Brittle materials obey the maximum-normal-stress criterion or, better, the modified-Mohr criterion, which accounts for different ultimate tensile and compressive strengths. Brittle fracture arises at the weakest flaw, consistent with Weibull statistics.

3.3 Design Equation

In design the failure criterion is combined with a factor of safety. For a ductile shaft under combined bending and torsion, the design equation combines flexural and shear stresses into a von Mises equivalent.

Example: Bracket. A cantilevered bracket carries a 2 kN transverse load at 150 mm from the wall. The bending stress at the root is \( \sigma = Mc/I \). With \( S_y = 300 \) MPa, a factor of safety of 2 demands that the maximum stress remain below 150 MPa, sizing the section modulus \( Z \geq 2 \) kN m / 150 MPa.

Chapter 4: Fatigue Analysis

4.1 Cyclic Loading

Most machine elements experience cyclic rather than static loads. The stress cycle is characterised by mean stress \( \sigma_m \) and alternating stress \( \sigma_a \) with \( \sigma_a = (\sigma_{max}-\sigma_{min})/2 \) and \( \sigma_m = (\sigma_{max}+\sigma_{min})/2 \).

4.2 Endurance Limit and Correction Factors

For many steels an endurance limit \( S_e' \) exists below which infinite life is achievable. A corrected endurance limit is

\[ S_e = k_a k_b k_c k_d k_e k_f S_e', \]

with factors for surface, size, load, temperature, reliability, and miscellaneous effects. Non-ferrous materials lack a true endurance limit; design uses a finite-life strength at \( 5\times 10^8 \) cycles.

4.3 Mean-Stress Corrections and Life

Goodman, Gerber, ASME-elliptic, and Soderberg criteria account for tensile mean stress. Basquin’s equation \( \sigma_a = \sigma_f'(2N)^b \) describes finite-life fatigue. Miner’s rule aggregates damage from variable amplitude loading.

Chapter 5: Welds

5.1 Weld Types and Strengths

Fillet and butt welds are the most common joint types. Strength depends on throat area and weld metal properties. Code-based allowable shear stresses on the throat of fillet welds typically range from 0.3 to 0.4 times the electrode ultimate tensile strength.

5.2 Stress in Welds

Welds are analysed as lines under direct and moment loads. For a fillet weld group under torsion, the maximum shear stress is

\[ \tau_{max} = \sqrt{\tau_{primary}^2 + \tau_{secondary}^2 + 2\tau_{primary}\tau_{secondary}\cos\alpha}, \]

where primary and secondary components arise from direct and moment-induced shears, respectively.

5.3 Fatigue of Welds

Welded joints possess reduced fatigue strength due to residual stresses, geometric notches, and metallurgical inhomogeneities. Code approaches (AWS, IIW) provide fatigue curves categorised by joint detail, and design uses the worst applicable category.

Chapter 6: Bolted Connections

6.1 Threaded Fastener Basics

Bolts are characterised by nominal diameter, thread pitch, proof strength, and grade. The tensile stress area is slightly larger than the minor-diameter area to reflect thread engagement.

6.2 Preload and Stiffness

A properly preloaded bolt sustains mostly constant load in service, enhancing fatigue life. The bolt-to-joint stiffness ratio \( C = k_b/(k_b + k_m) \) sets the share of external load carried by the bolt. Torque-tension relations \( T = K d F_i \) provide a first-order tightening guide, with \( K \) depending on friction and thread geometry.

6.3 Failure Modes

Bolted joints fail by bolt yielding, bolt fatigue, thread stripping, bearing, shear tear-out, and plate yielding. Each mode has its own design equation, and the governing mode sets capacity.

Chapter 7: Springs

7.1 Helical Compression Springs

For a helical compression spring of wire diameter \( d \), mean coil diameter \( D \), and active coils \( N_a \), the spring rate is

\[ k = \frac{G d^4}{8 D^3 N_a}. \]

Maximum shear stress at the inside of the coil includes a Wahl correction factor \( K_W \) to account for curvature and direct shear.

7.2 Fatigue of Springs

Springs often see cyclic loading. Design uses corrected endurance limits for spring wire, mean-stress corrections, and shot-peening to introduce compressive residual stresses that enhance fatigue strength.

7.3 Other Spring Types

Extension springs, torsion springs, Belleville washers, leaf springs, and constant-force springs each have specialised analysis. Material selection (music wire, chromium vanadium, stainless, beryllium copper) depends on environment, frequency, and temperature.

Chapter 8: Shafts

8.1 Design Loads

Shafts carry torque from power sources to loads while supporting bending from radial forces on gears, pulleys, and sprockets. Shaft design combines static and fatigue analyses at critical cross-sections.

8.2 ASME Shaft Equation

The DE-Goodman criterion for a rotating shaft with steady torque and fully reversed bending gives a diameter

\[ d = \left(\frac{16 n}{\pi}\left\{\frac{1}{S_e}\left[4(K_f M_a)^2 + 3(K_{fs}T_m)^2\right]^{1/2} + \frac{1}{S_{ut}}\left[4(K_f M_m)^2 + 3(K_{fs}T_a)^2\right]^{1/2}\right\}\right)^{1/3}, \]

where \( K_f \) and \( K_{fs} \) are fatigue stress concentration factors for bending and torsion.

8.3 Deflection, Vibration, and Keys

Shaft design considers bending deflection at bearings, torsional deflection, and critical speeds that excite resonance. Keys, splines, set screws, and press fits transmit torque between shaft and hub; each has specific load-capacity and manufacturing considerations.

Back to top